CompleteMartialArts.com - Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan

|
List Price: $18.00
Our Price: $12.24
Your Save: $ 5.76 ( 32% )
Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours
Manufacturer: Harper Perennial
|
Average Customer Rating:     

|
|
Binding: Paperback Dewey Decimal Number: 952.033092 EAN: 9780060931308 ISBN: 0060931302 Label: Harper Perennial Manufacturer: Harper Perennial Number Of Items: 1 Number Of Pages: 832 Publication Date: 2001-09-01 Publisher: Harper Perennial Release Date: 2001-09-04 Studio: Harper Perennial
|
|
|
|
|
|
Editorial Reviews:
|
|
Winner of the Pulitzer Prize In this groundbreaking biography of the Japanese emperor Hirohito, Herbert P. Bix offers the first complete, unvarnished look at the enigmatic leader whose sixty-three-year reign ushered Japan into the modern world. Never before has the full life of this controversial figure been revealed with such clarity and vividness. Bix shows what it was like to be trained from birth for a lone position at the apex of the nation's political hierarchy and as a revered symbol of divine status. Influenced by an unusual combination of the Japanese imperial tradition and a modern scientific worldview, the young emperor gradually evolves into his preeminent role, aligning himself with the growing ultranationalist movement, perpetuating a cult of religious emperor worship, resisting attempts to curb his power, and all the while burnishing his image as a reluctant, passive monarch. Here we see Hirohito as he truly was: a man of strong will and real authority. Supported by a vast array of previously untapped primary documents, Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan is perhaps most illuminating in lifting the veil on the mythology surrounding the emperor's impact on the world stage. Focusing closely on Hirohito's interactions with his advisers and successive Japanese governments, Bix sheds new light on the causes of the China War in 1937 and the start of the Asia-Pacific War in 1941. And while conventional wisdom has had it that the nation's increasing foreign aggression was driven and maintained not by the emperor but by an elite group of Japanese militarists, the reality, as witnessed here, is quite different. Bix documents in detail the strong, decisive role Hirohito played in wartime operations, from the takeover of Manchuria in 1931 through the attack on Pearl Harbor and ultimately the fateful decision in 1945 to accede to an unconditional surrender. In fact, the emperor stubbornly prolonged the war effort and then used the horrifying bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, together with the Soviet entrance into the war, as his exit strategy from a no-win situation. From the moment of capitulation, we see how American and Japanese leaders moved to justify the retention of Hirohito as emperor by whitewashing his wartime role and reshaping the historical consciousness of the Japanese people. The key to this strategy was Hirohito's alliance with General MacArthur, who helped him maintain his stature and shed his militaristic image, while MacArthur used the emperor as a figurehead to assist him in converting Japan into a peaceful nation. Their partnership ensured that the emperor's image would loom large over the postwar years and later decades, as Japan began to make its way in the modern age and struggled -- as it still does -- to come to terms with its past. Until the very end of a career that embodied the conflicting aims of Japan's development as a nation, Hirohito remained preoccupied with politics and with his place in history. Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan provides the definitive account of his rich life and legacy. Meticulously researched and utterly engaging, this book is proof that the history of twentieth-century Japan cannot be understood apart from the life of its most remarkable and enduring leader.
|
|
|
Spotlight customer reviews:
|
Customer Rating:      Summary: Will greatly expand your understanding of Japan Comment: Herbert Bix's book more than amply rewards the patient reader. Many of the previous reviews have focused on the emperor's responsibility for World War II, and that's certainly an important theme of Bix's superbly researched book. However, the conclusions the book draws are far from black and white. Instead, Bix lays out his version of the facts and lets those facts speak for themselves.
It's an extremely effective means of rhetoric, and you will find, the closer you read, that Bix leaves oceans of ambiguity regarding the emperor's wartime role. Where Bix's arguments have the least flexibility is where he articulates, using sociology, history, and the personal upbringing of Hirohito, the point that the imperial role during and before the war was far more than symbolic. Yet his discussion of how the cabinet, the parliament, and the imperial advisers circumscribed and/or expanded that role shows that whether the emperor's role was great or small, it defies easy definition.
This opaque method of wielding power is so intuitively correct for anyone who has studied Japanese politics, that it smacks of great truth. And whether you believe that the emperor was a tyrant, a figurehead, or something in between, Bix's sophisticated attempt to trace the myriad strands of power, politics, and battlefield outcomes illuminates Japanese politics and power in a way that no other modern history been able to do, at least in English.
The personalities and events surrounding this extraordinary historical figure make for tantalizing reading. Many previous reviews have described the writing as boring, but it's nothing of the kind if you're interested in the details that made up war and pre-war decisions. Consensus, factions, deference to hierarchy, moving up through the ranks, and an incredible attention to the finest details are all characteristics that will be immediately recognizable to anyone who has lived in Japan for long. Bix's lifetime and intimate ties to Japan are reflected in his thinking and in his style. It's rich and rewarding, but certainly not low hanging fruit.
If you're looking for a thoughtful and thought provoking view on the modernization of Japan, this book provides it. The relationship between Meiji and Showa is fascinating for its scantiness and for the profound impact that the grandfather had on the grandson. The description of the postwar imperial reign creates a cacophonous dissonance with Hirohito's earlier power and involvement in government that literally hearkens back to the occasional Roman emperors who left the seat of power to putter in their gardens.
If you enjoy this book, regardless of your conclusions, even half as much as I did, it will have been worth every single penny.
Customer Rating:      Summary: Lèse majesté Comment: It's more of an academic book, with an apparently controversial thesis to defend, rather than something like David Halbarstam would write. So the firs third is pretty slow and arcane, with lots of details about Japanese politics, and history, with relevant Japanese terms tossed in. Things pick up when WWII starts. I missed an overview of Japanese culture, national psychology and interviews with people who lived through this time. But it's not that kind of a book. It's worth reading, I would recommend it for a very different perspective than you get on the History Channel, where they love to refight Midway over and over. Japanese war planners were tacticians, and overly optimistic, with their heads in the sand. None of them, nor the Emperor, served the people well.
Customer Rating:      Summary: Biased perspective - "History" by Objective Comment: I've read this book twice, and came to the same conclusions as Mr. O'Neil (before reading his review). Bix seems to almost bend over backwards to paint leftist and communists in idealized light, akin to the current vogue iconization of Che' as a liberating hero. Never understood why most intellectuals can't see communism/socialism as the same thing as facism - move far enough to the left and you meet the far right.
Anyhow, to provide an Abstract for the books thesis: Factions in the US governement - lead by left-hating McArthur - used Hirohito after the war as a tool to suppress communism in Japan and help Chaing-Kai-Shek fight against Mao. This was accomplished by white-washing the evils of Hirohito, who was a key architect of not only WWII, but also of brutal suppression of communist liberators seeking only democracy for Japan.
And don't forget to throw in unreferenced purgoratives that support your thesis ... my favorite is this one: a government minister said "Hirohito wept when he heard the judgement against Tojo." No reference is given, no name, no context or location. Its just a cheap shot akin to Michael Moore journalism. And there are NUMEROUS such examples of this in the book.
A better title of the book would be .. "Too bad Mao's revolution couldn't have spread successfully into Japan: Darn that Hirohito and his right-wing enabler McArthur."
Customer Rating:      Summary: Overrated Comment: Perhaps I had too many expectations of this book, because it won a Pulitzer Prize and other awards. I enjoyed the wording and style employed by the author; the sentences and paragraphs were both very fluid and readable. My main complaint with this book is that I do not feel that I learned much by reading it, i.e., I do not believe the factual information to words ratio (facts/words) was high enough for me to recommend it to someone else. In some parts of the book, it seems that the author attempts to employ a written form of filibusters. Usually after reading a few pages or chapters of a non-fiction book, I have to sit back to take in all the information. This book never necessitated such a pause in my reading. In short, I believe this book may be interesting to those few people extremely interested in Hirohito's role during and after World War II. But, I believe most people will agree that the best one-word summary of this book would be as follows: Overrated.
Customer Rating:      Summary: An Enjoyable Bio on an Interesting Figure Comment: I actually found this one in a bookstore while I was in Japan, then bought it over here in the states. Hirohito is probably not read about much here, but he should be because his life impacts Asian thought and politics to this day.
While everyone knows that Hitler was responsible for the death of probably 12 million during the holocaust, few people realize that Hirohito was responsible for the death of 20 million people. Therefore, Korea, and China still harbor feelings due to WWII.
Bix explains how Hirohito escaped war crimes trials. This is what makes the book somewhat controversial. Bix maintains that Hirohito played an active role in the Asian agression by Japan before and during WWII, rather than just being a mere figurehead. He also spends quite a bit of time covering the contributions that McArthur made in rebuilding Japan after WWII.
Bix's writing style is pleasant. Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan seems very well researched. This book is the place to start if you want to understand U.S. - Japanese relations.
|
|
|
|
|
|